Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Blast From the Past


I work in education. It’s a big deal right now that there are so many minority children in our schools. They are used as an excuse sometimes for schools that don’t achieve the state’s academic goals.

But where I grew up, which is right where I still live, we always had a diverse population of students. This is the first grade in 1955. (Not mine, my brother’s.) There are 5 little white bread kids, 3 Hispanic kids, and I think a Japanese boy. Even though this wasn’t my class, I remember all their names. It wasn’t unusual for us to know everyone in grades 1 through 8 of our little school (no kindergarten),

There were actually more kids in this class. At least one girl whose parents had cattle in the mountains and didn’t move back to the valley until a month of so after school started every year. And there were a several more Mexican kids whose families didn’t come until spring and left in the fall after hops had been picked. We had students who barely spoke any English sometimes.

I don’t recall that any of this was a problem. Kids were pretty much judged on their own merits, and in those days academic excellence was not the only measuring stick. You had an opportunity to be good at volleyball, dodge ball, tetherball, folk dancing, singing, and any number of other things that didn’t involve books. The playground was pretty much kid territory, the teachers stayed inside and maybe watched out the window as they smoked their cigarettes.

The teacher of this class was Mrs. Butler. She taught us all to read in first grade, I don’t recall that it was that difficult. Her class was first and second grade. I don't recall that was a problem, either.

Nowdays it’s a big deal to have all students reading by third grade, and it’s sometimes not accomplished, schools say, because there are so many kids whose parents don’t speak English. Our school was at least half Hispanic.

My cousin Nancy is one of the kids in this class. She was a teacher herself until she retired. Maybe she has some input on this subject. Maybe there WERE kids who were getting left behind then, and I just didn’t notice it because it was no big deal. There was no state-mandated test in those days that pressured schools to pressure kids.

It just seems like things worked better, though.

I’m having a lot of fun going through the old pictures and scanning them. Here is one of my baby brother and I from 1951.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

jan i agree with you. it will be interesting to hear what the teachers of today think. loved your pictures. beverly

Nancy said...

Things sure have changed in 53 years!! What I remember about Mrs. Butler's class was that it was 1st-3rd. She didn't hold us back to our grade, but encouraged us to succeed. I was able to be working with 3rd grade materials by the end of 1st grade. Then we moved to Rancho and 2nd grade was a bit of shock for me because I was now told I had to do 2nd grade stuff. I wonder what my experience would have been if we stayed in Sloughhouse.

Why are today's students not as successful as we once were?

Though we had Spanish-speaking kids in our classes, they were quick to pick up English and the teacher only had to deal with one foreign language. Today's classrooms have many different languages in one class, making it much more difficult to give the kids what they need.

Standards that are set way too high and are not developmentally appropriate.

The math I taught in 5th grade was what I took in 9th grade as a very good math student. Even though many studies have been done to show that math should be studied in depth, with fewer areas covered each year, students are required to speed through it so that all 12 concepts can be mastered before testing. It's tough on teachers, and miserable for kids who aren't math wizards.

Many science concepts were way over students heads and difficult to teach to 34 kids. We had way too much science to cover in the time we had, which meant kids who were struggling with the subject were out of luck, because we had to move on.

Testing is not developmentally appropriate and covers subject matter not included in that grade.

I don't think that we had as much testing in the 50's and 60's, at least I don't remember it. I think if we would have had the same testing then as we do today, we might be surprised at how "low" kids were.

Today's families are very different from the 50's. Both parents are working. Kids are in lots of activities outside of school, which are great. However, many times the sports programs get in the way of homework. Kids are spending too much time in front of a screen - television or computer. They become much more passive and less creative or inquisitive. Many kids spend more time staring at a screen than they do interacting with humans. Not good.

Okay, enough rambling on and on. I have many more thoughts about schools, parent involvement, community involvement, regulations, testing, etc. But . . . I'm moving on. Thanks for getting me to think about this.
Cousin Nancy

Jan Blawat said...

Thanks Nancy, I knew you'd have some insightful things to say. I remember sitting in a corner in Mrs. Butler's class reading The Yearling while everyone else studied phonics. You're right, we weren't kept at a grade level. If you whizzed through one math book, they just handed you the next one and said, "go at it."

We didn't have afterschool sports, we played sports at school. On Fridays most of the school got on a bus and they took us to another school - like Dillard or Lee - to play whatever sport was in season. Except no soccer. I don't remember much homework anyway. We got home from school, grabbed our bikes, and rode out in the fields until dark.

I've worked at creating assessments for 15 years now, and often wonder what the value is to the kids.

And you're right, Spanish used to be the only foreign language. Now there are several. Not only that, but community college students now have teachers in some classes who barely speak English. In one of Bob's math classes at CRC, the teacher spoke with a very heavy Chinese accent. Some of the students didn't speak English well, either. I guess it was a struggle for everyone, but they made it work.

Now is a good time to be beyond school and the ed biz.